Well, he's giving up — albeit not really; it's just what he says — because it's all a bit overwhelming to him. By his own admission, he's been stuck in that minor-pentatonic box for over 30 years, and if you stick to such a narrow confinement for so long because you think that the blues is all there is to playing an electric guitar, and that five notes is all it takes for playing the blues proper, then the sudden confrontation with all the other aspects of music theory (and how to put them into practice) will certainly be overwhelming.
Even though I certainly don't consider myself a virtuoso — albeit that I did for a while have the ambition to become one when I was younger, and have effectively been called a virtuoso by three people, two of whom were guitarists (of whom one was himself an incredibly talented artist) — my own learning process was quite different from that of Lee.
I had already been playing various musical instruments from when I was very little, and I've also always passionately loved music, but it wasn't until my early teenage years that I really became obsessed with the electric guitar. Nevertheless, my parents were not keen on the idea, and so it took until the summer vacation of the year that I had turned 16 before I got my first guitar, and for that matter, it was an electric, because the electric guitar was what it had always been about for me. Acoustics were cool, but the electric was where the fun was to be had, and they looked so awesome on TV.
But that said, even though I come from a musical family — my dad used to be a trumpet player in his younger days, and we had professional musicians on both sides of the family — my parents did not consider a career in music a respectable job, and so I have never had any formal music training, and I also never got any guitar lessons. I had to learn and discover everything by myself, with the help of a thin booklet with the most used chord shapes, and some chords that my contemporaries at school taught me.
Another difference is that, unlike Lee — and unlike many of my contemporaries who also played an electric guitar — I was never into the blues, or even into blues-inspired guitarists like Jimmy Page, Eric Clapton or Jimi Hendrix. I didn't even have the financial resources to buy a lot of full-size albums — although I did have a few — and so I was mostly listening to the radio, and specifically, the weekly Belgian top-30, and occasionally, the Dutch top-30 and the British top-20. And then there were the weekly top-20/top-30 shows on Dutch television.
As such, my own influences are very eclectic, and then there were also the influences from old
black & white movie score music, from the medieval (and other) folk music that served as the backdrop for TV-series set in the middle ages, from Spanish and Latin-American music played on nylon-string acoustic guitars, and from the music that my parents listened to. Given that my dad used to be a trumpet player, he was very much into the Glenn Miller Orchestra, and I loved that sound. Both of my parents loved The Platters, and I loved that music too. And my mom was very much into crooners — Frank Sinatra, Tom Jones and Englebert Humperdinck — and I liked some of that stuff too.
Either way, all of it made my musical background very diatonic, rather than pentatonic, and so I also approached my guitar playing from a diatonic vantage. As a teenager, I also listened to bands like Boston, in which the guitar solos were almost always diatonic, as well as the very Latin-sounding ballads of Carlos Santana — things like
"Samba Pa Ti",
"Europa",
"Moonflower", et al — and the also fairly diatonic solos of Mark Knopfler. I liked progressive rock, but unlike most of my contemporaries, I also liked Motown stuff, soul, disco and funk. And there's quite a bit of jazz guitar in those particular styles.
I did also pick up some pentatonic stuff from Lindsey Buckingham's guitar work on Fleetwood Mac's
"Rumours" album, but that was mostly because he was playing a white Les Paul Custom — which I had so far never seen before, and which I thought looked really cool — and because of his sound on that album. He was using the preamp of a broken Echoplex unit as a distortion device, which gave his Les Paul a really warm and creamy distortion sound. But I didn't really associate his playing with the blues — mainly because I didn't really know what the blues as a musical genre sounded like — and it didn't change a single thing to my diatonic approach to guitar playing. It would only be much, much later that I became more familiar with the blues, and with blues scales.
Now, most guitarists who play the blues, or who play blues-inspired solos, approach the blues scale as a pentatonic scale with two blue notes added. For people not familiar with the term "blue notes", they are notes that fall out of the diatonic scale, which itself, if you're playing in the key of C Major, comprises only the white keys on the piano. So, sticking with C Major, the diatonic scale is C - D - E - F - G - A - B - C, giving you the familiar "do re mi fa so la ti do" melody, as Julie Andrews sang in the musical
"The Sound Of Music".
Reducing the diatonic scale of C Major to a pentatonic one, you then get C - D - E - G - A - C — the addition of that last note actually makes it a hexatonic scale, but it's just another C, one octave up from the root note, so we don't count it as part of the scale. Therefore, strictly speaking, C Major Pentatonic is C - D - E - G - A, or "do re mi so la", which means you're dropping two notes from the normal diatonic C Major scale, being the F (fa) and the B (ti). And then what the blues scale does, is add two notes to that scale again, but the two added notes are blue notes, corresponding to — in the case of C Major — two black keys on the piano, namely a sharp 4th and a sharp 2nd (or flat 3rd, if you will. As such the C Major blues scale becomes C - D - D#/Eb - E - F# - G - A.
The D#/Eb blue note can be referred to as either a sharp 2nd or a flat 3rd because neither the normal 2nd (D) nor the normal 3rd (E) are substituted by the blue note — the blue note is simply added in between them — unlike in the case of the F#, which replaces the F in the diatonic C Major scale; the 4th (F) is raised by a semitone, rather than that the 5th (G) is lowered by a semitone, because the 5th is still there in the blues version of the scale, and therefore the F# is referred to in the key of C Major as a sharp 4th, rather than as a flat 5th.
Bringing this back to what I said earlier, most guitarists who play the blues or who play blues-inspired solos do indeed approach the blues scale as a pentatonic scale with two blue notes added, but with my diatonic background, I don't look at it in that manner. Instead, I see the blues scale as a full diatonic scale with two
chromaticisms, while still being aware of the original diatonic notes that were omitted (B) or altered (F to F#, and a D#/Eb added in between D and E) against the diatonic scale. And this in turn then opens up the path toward thinking chromatically — seeing all 12 of the notes in an octave — and exploiting this for inserting chromatic passing notes in between the diatonic ones.
And so that is how I myself approach the blues scale; I don't
"feel the blues" as such, but instead, it all simply becomes a greater collection of notes to play around with. But my approach to melody is always primarily diatonic, because I want my solos to sound musical. Many jazz musicians for instance know all of this stuff by heart but lack a sense of melody — they know exactly what they're doing in terms of the music theory, but the notes they play sound dissonant rather than musical.
Something I also do like a lot — and which harks back to medieval music — is the concept of modes, something that also gets used in jazz and progressive rock/metal quite a lot. When used well, modal phrasing can sound very interesting in both solos and in chord progressions. But that's a topic for another day.
Anywho, by thinking he could get away by simply learning how to play solos using only the minor-pentatonic scale, Lee had seriously painted himself into a corner, and breaking out of that again is very difficult, as well as overwhelming, due to the complexity of all the things players like Lee dismissed out of hand in their decision to limit themselves only to pentatonics instead of opening themselves up to the grander musical reality beyond
the white man's attempt at blues. This doesn't mean that Lee would be unable to learn all of this (for him) new stuff, but it'll require quite a bit of effort, and especially so because he's been doing it "his way" for over 30 years, and old habits are hard to break.
Bookmarks