PDA

View Full Version : The Great Debate - Joe Rogan, Graham Hancock, Randall Carlson & Michael Shermer - JRE #961



Kathy
13th December 2017, 08:52
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=5568&v=ta_9na0-mwA

"Published on 20 May 2017 by Sacred Geometry International

Streamed live on May 16, 2017

Graham Hancock is an English author and journalist, well known for books such as "Fingerprints Of The Gods" & his latest book "Magicians of the Gods". Randall Carlson is a master builder and architectural designer, teacher, geometrician, geomythologist, geological explorer and renegade scholar.

Michael Shermer is a science writer, historian of science, founder of The Skeptics Society, and Editor in Chief of its magazine Skeptic."

Herbert
15th December 2017, 18:45
This is an interesting discussion in terms of speculating on the "evidence".

But they are assuming human evolution has continuity. They are looking for an evolutionary process when in fact the megaliths were built in an attempt to counter-act the de-volutionary process humans were experiencing. Those attempts were doomed to failure and we are now on the verge of realising why.

Also the dating techniques used are not reliable. For example geologists assume sedimentary deposits are a simple filling in over time but they are much more complicated than they presume.

Understandably, but still unwarranted, assumptions are made by archaeologists. They automatically assume megaliths are not utilitarian so must be religious. They can't get into the heads of the very practical minds of our predecessors. But worse yet are the university and Biblical "rules" they must play by. To break those "laws" based on rational observation of artifacts means losing tenure, a job, shunning, and becoming an outcast.

Still it's interesting to listen to their logical mistakes, their influenced beliefs based on 'Annunaki gods' lies and their lack of having imagination equal to that of the people they study.

Aianawa
15th December 2017, 21:39
Did not matter where upon the past/history/bs/truth spectrum one was, this when it first aired, monkey minded and cleared brain snot very well, still doing so imo, was great work by Joe an co.

Elen
16th December 2017, 09:52
This is an interesting discussion in terms of speculating on the "evidence".

But they are assuming human evolution has continuity. They are looking for an evolutionary process when in fact the megaliths were built in an attempt to counter-act the de-volutionary process humans were experiencing. Those attempts were doomed to failure and we are now on the verge of realising why.

Also the dating techniques used are not reliable. For example geologists assume sedimentary deposits are a simple filling in over time but they are much more complicated than they presume.

Understandably, but still unwarranted, assumptions are made by archaeologists. They automatically assume megaliths are not utilitarian so must be religious. They can't get into the heads of the very practical minds of our predecessors. But worse yet are the university and Biblical "rules" they must play by. To break those "laws" based on rational observation of artifacts means losing tenure, a job, shunning, and becoming an outcast.

Still it's interesting to listen to their logical mistakes, their influenced beliefs based on 'Annunaki gods' lies and their lack of having imagination equal to that of the people they study.

The funny thing Herbert is that while you saw only the negatives in the documentary...I actually saw so many positives that the negatives just disappeared. I saw the wonderful moment when the two differing sides actually met and discussed their disagreements and came to the conclusion that they should keep in contact for future talks.

But that was at the end of the video...did you see that?